Summary: A section of track which allows a train to reverse direction is a Reverse Loop, sometimes called a Balloon Track. These were used in place of a turntable to easily turn around a passenger train for the return trip, while maintaining the correct orientation of the cars. Electrically they represent a problem on the layout, as Rail A meets Rail B at the turnout. Careful wiring, installation of gaps, and a method of switching rail phase are required. Wyes also require this attention.
- When you heard about Digital Command Control and all its advantages they told you that you wouldn't need to worry about polarity issues and reversing sections.
- Not quite true!
Except for 3-rail track, all electric train layouts have to be specially wired when it comes to reversing sections of track. A reversing section allows an engine (or train) to enter in one direction, and leave on the same track heading back the way it came. Reversing sections include: wyes or triangles, turntables, and reversing loops.
Digital Command Control has phase issues, and a reversing section will cause a dead short if not wired correctly. With DCC, Rail B is held to ground while Rail A is Positive, which then flips (Rail A is held to ground and Rail B becomes Positive) to construct the DCC digital waveform.
Since DCC uses a digital signal on the rails to provide both commands and power to the decoders, there is no polarity issue, as the signal consists of only logical high and low values. There is no concept of polarity with digital, as there are no positive or negative values. The phase issue is that Rail A is always the logical opposite of Rail B.
In a traditional layout, a reversing section is insulated from the rest of the layout. It is powered through an independent reversing switch. The train enters the reversing section and, whilst the train was totally inside the reversing section, the power to the main line was reversed. When the train leaves the reversing section there is no display of sparks!
This must be done with DCC too. The difference is an automatic reverser can automate this process by throwing a 'soft' switch. As a train enters or leaves the reversing section, the reverser detects the short circuit caused by a train entering or leaving the isolated section and reverses the phase of the isolated reversing section of track. This happens quickly enough that the train continues on its way unimpeded. With DCC, direction of travel is determined by the decoder, not by the track.
This behavior has some side effects that bear consideration. First, a single reverser may be used to control more than one reversing section. The constraint is only one train may be entering or leaving reversing sections controlled by a single reverser at a time. Second, the reversing section must be long enough to contain all of the train that may trigger the short -- engines, cars with electrical circuitry, cars with conductive wheels. Care must also be taken that the current capacity of the booster and wiring is sufficient that the reverser detects the short in a timely manner and performs its function. If the booster or power management device acts too quickly things will not work well.
The LDT KSM-SG is different than most reverse-loop modules, the reversal phase of the reverse-loop will be performed without a short circuit due to two sensor-tracks located at the entrance and at the exit of the reverse-loop.
Application Example 1: Reverse Loop
The AR1 is Digitrax's product to provide automatic reversing of track phase whilst a train passes through a reversing section. Although the AR1 is used in these examples and diagrams, there are many other products from various manufacturers which work just as well (and some argue better) than the Digitrax AR1. We highly recommend you check out various reversing units from various manufacturers and vendors before making your final decision. A Frog Juicer can also be used in this application.
Connection is simple via the two pairs of wires: one feeds track power to the AR1 (shown on the right, above) and the other feeds from the AR1 to the loop. The gaps in the rails are essential: they isolate the two opposite phases of electric power (see DCC Tutorial (Power)). Electrical gaps must exist in both the places shown. These gaps can be made by using insulated rail joiners or cutting the rails and filling the gaps with an insulated material such as styrene. Other devices available on the market work in much the same way.
When a locomotive bridges the gap, rather than stalling or shorting out the track bus, the autoreverser switches the phase.
Application Example 2: Reversing Triangle or Wye
Whereas reversing loops are rare on full-sized railways, triangular junctions, or wyes are quite common. The AR1 can also be used for these. The triangle may connect to a separate line (as in full-sized practice) or may simply be a convenient spur siding.
A wye was often used to turn a locomotive where a turntable was not available.
The track feed connects to the AR1 input just as in the reversing loop case. The AR1 output feeds the spur. The two double gaps on the right are essential because they isolate the different power phases.
It is important to note that it is not possible to make any other feed connections to the spur other than via the AR1 unit.
- The double gap on the main line marked with an asterisk (*) is required if the turnout or points have a live frog.
Troubleshooting a Reverse Loop
Gaps are needed to isolate the loop from the track leading to it. They can be created using an insulated rail joiner to connect sections of track, or by cutting a gap with a razor saw.
- If the gap is created by cutting the rails, it is important to fill the gap with a non-conducting material such as styrene. Filling the gap with an appropriate thickness of styrene will prevent the gap from closing up during expansion cycles. While the expansion of your rail is not very much, it can be enough to close the gap. Movement of the benchwork during expansion and contraction can also contribute.
Carefully shaping the styrene filler can create an almost invisible gap in the rails. Just insert the spacer, use a little ACC to bond it to the rails, and shape it with files and knives.
The gaps must not be staggered to prevent other issues from occurring. Definite boundaries between the loop and the inbound/outbound track is required.
As with all trackwork, proper wiring is important. Poor wiring can impede the operation of an autoreverser by limiting the current flow. It requires a short circuit to happen before it will act, and enough current must flow to trigger it. The autoreverse unit must also be wired correctly, using the main power bus wiring. It should not be connected using light gauge wires directly to the track. Some auto reverse units may not work correctly if wired after a power management device.
Adjustments or changes may be needed to ensure it works, as some boosters may trigger faster than reverser. The reverser should be the first and only device to trigger when a phase mismatch occurs.
If the reverse loop is feed by a different booster than the lead in track, the use of a proper sized booster common is important. Limiting the current with poor wiring between the boosters could cause issues.
The auto reverser may need some adjustment to the trip point, if possible. If the trip current is too high, the unit may not react all the time, or only under certain conditions.
(Please use this area to list and provide links to devices which will handle reversing sections.)
- Digitrax PM42
- Digitrax AR1
- Lenz LK200 (In German)
- LDT KSM-SG
- MRC AD520
- OpenDCC Reverser
- Zimo MX7, MX7/3
- Power Shield X and OG-AR from DCC Specialties
- DCC Dual Frog Juicer and Auto-Reverser from Tam Valley
- KSM-SG-F by Littfinski DatenTechnik (LDT)
- NCE AR10